Best Mechanical/ Fixed Blade broadheads reviews for 2018
Bow and arrow hunting is a complex sport that requires not only practiced skill but the right equipment. Selecting the right broadhead is critical to successful bow and arrow hunting for a variety of game animals. Whether hunters are using a cross bow, a recurve bow, a compound bow or a longbow, it is important to match the correct arrow and broadhead for maximum hunting success as well as hunter safety.
1 (Editor's Choice)
Bow hunters selecting broadheads should give some thought to what game they are hunting, what bow they are using, and consider the advantages and disadvantages to each kind of broadhead before making a final selection. Some broadheads can be used with multiple kinds of bows; however, there are some that should absolutely not be used with certain bows.
Categories of Broadheads
Three main categories of broadheads exist, and it pays to understand the design, advantages and disadvantages of each.
Are the most traditional, basic design option. These broadheads are typically secured to the arrow shaft with an adhesive or a screw and used with lower draw weight bows. Most fixed-blade broadheads have tips that pierce upon contact, which is a great advantage for hunters who are seeking game with tough skin such as bear or elk. The major disadvantage to fixed-blade broadheads is their need to be resharpened regularly and their incapability with faster bows.
Are very versatile and compatible with most bows. One major advantage is that these broadheads can simply be replaced when they become dull. Most modern designs have positive flight and penetration features; however, replaceable-blade broadheads can be more costly and somewhat less durable.
Which are also known as expandable broadheads, can be top-of-the-line in terms of flight features. Hunters going after thinner skinned game animals, and those who successfully position themselves broadside can achieve great success with mechanical broadheads. Although these expandable broadheads work well with fussy bows and feature excellent penetration, they are not as forgiving in poorly planned shots. Bowhunters field tested mechanical broadheads and results can be viewed below.
Broadhead and Bow Compatibility
One of the most important questions that hunters must address is “What kind of broadhead is most compatible with what kind of bow?”
Hunters using traditional bows tend to employ heavy draw weight arrows in order to make up for lagging arrow velocity and increase penetration force. This category of hunters may use broadheads that measure 300 grains and have a head that penetrates on contact. These traditional bows should never be used with expandable broadheads.
Hunters using compound bows that have draw weights of between 30 pounds and 50 pounds are most likely to be using an incorrect broadhead. The best broadhead for lighter draw weight bows is a two- or three-blade cut-on-contact broadhead, not a mechanical one. Those who must violate this advice should at least ensure that an expandable broadhead features a cutting diameter of no more than one-and-a-half inches.
Those hunters who like to use compound bows with draw weights of over 50 pounds have the greatest variety and flexibility when choosing a broadhead. However, the flexibility comes with a great deal of responsibility, and shot placement becomes much more important in successful hunting results.
Broadhead Safety Guidelines
One major selling point of all quality broadheads is their sharpness. Unlike bullets, broadheads sever blood vessels leading to death by hemorrhaging of the animal. As a result, the risk of hunter injuries is high from these razor-sharp broadheads. Here are some guidelines to ensure that broadheads are used correctly and safely.
- Use a wrench specially designed to shelter the razor-sharp blades while tightening the broadhead to the arrow shaft. Without this wrench, a small error can result in serious injury.
- Sharpen broadheads by making sure movements are not toward your body or hands.
- Cover broadheads while transporting your hunting equipment. Each time you move your hunting gear from the home to the car or from your car to the hunting site, you risk injury if broadheads are visible.
- Find all components of the broadhead while field-dressing an animal. Loose parts that are lost inside the game can cause injury if caution is not practiced.
Which Broadhead for Which Game?
Hunters vary by many factors. Some enjoy hunting big game while others like finding smaller animals. Some only kill dangerous or pesky animals. Some prefer firearms while others prefer bow hunting. Regardless of your hunting preferences, here are some guidelines when selecting broadheads to match your preferred game animals.
Rare Big Game Animals
Although these big game animals are not the most popular for hunters, they are certainly at the top of the list in terms of hide thickness, muscle strength and danger. To take animals such as moose, grizzly bears, bison and oxen down safely, humanely and quickly, hunters will want to use a single-piece fixed broadhead that is made of all steel.
Such heavy-duty construction with a razor-sharp edge and excellent hunting skill can break through the bone and muscle in order to hit vital organs quickly. Although there is an inverse relationship between penetration and cutting diameter, in this case, it may make be wise to ensure that the penetration is deeper to complete the kill quickly. These large animals can be dangerous and simply wounding big game may signal significant trouble for the hunter.
Common Big Game Animals
Most serious hunters will be going after black bears, wild hogs, or whitetail deer. Many of these animals still feature tough hides, lots of muscle and possible danger, requiring broadheads that are strong and durable. Select a broadhead that can break through their hides and create a large enough wound so you can follow the blood. Some of the best broadheads for this group of game animals feature all-steel construction with replaceable blades.
Lightweight Animals: Smaller species of deer and animals, including black-tailed deer and some antelope varieties, have much thinner hides and not as much muscle as the big game animals. For hunting lightweight animals, hunters may choose mechanical, multi-blade broadheads, which will easily puncture the thinner hides and expand, which can successfully create a blood trail.
Small Game Animals and Birds
This small game category includes rabbits, wild turkeys or other pest animals like raccoons and coyotes. Although it can be difficult to hit vital areas, these small game creatures have very thin skins to puncture. In this case, some mechanical broadheads may work, but hunters may want to explore small game broadheads as well. These broadheads result in death from a blunt edge with follow-up from curved blades.
1 (Editor's Choice)
Best Broadhead Reviews
I have taken a look at the best broadhead's that is currently on the market and have chosen seven top broadheads for your consideration.
For those hunters targeting big game animals, the diamond-cut sharpness of the G5 Montec broadhead will do the trick. With its single-piece construction, this all-steel durable broadhead will pierce tough skin and heavy muscle on contact, resulting in a quick and safe kill of larger animals.
The Montec broadheads feature a one-and-one-eighth cutting diameter and comes in three grain weights. Select from 85-grain, 100-grain or 125-grain options in a three-pack selection. These broadheads are completely spin tested.
Although Montec broadheads are noted for their precision flights, life-long durability and razor-sharpness, they can be somewhat difficult to sharpen without learning the correct technique. They may also be a little noisier than other broadheads in flight. Overall, these broadheads can work well for hunters who are seeking grizzly bears, elk, moose or bison.
- Good for big game animals
- 100% steel construction
- Multiple grain options
- Precision flights
- Diamond sharpness
- Somewhat noisy in flight
- Difficult to sharpen
These expandable broadheads, weighing 100 grains, are a good choice for hunters who are focused on medium-sized game such as whitetail deer, javelina or black-tailed deer. This durable broadhead leaves a two-inch cut channel, which allows hunters to follow a clear blood trail to the killed game. Although the larger cutting diameter typically means less penetration, medium-sized game usually have thinner hides and less muscle mass to break through.
The rear-deploying broadheads are sold in a six-pack replacement blade package with o-rings and can be used with crossbows as well as recurve bows. Stainless-steel blades provide durability and sharpness for a quick and efficient kill while an an aerodynamic ferrule ensures accuracy. The Precision Hunting broadhead features a special design that helps the arrow cut through the hide and penetrate the vital organs for a quick kill.
Broadheads, in general, can experience some accuracy problems because the wider blades feature a greater surface area, which can generate more friction, affect flight patterns, and cause more issues if there is wind. They are needed, however, to generate larger cutting diameters to ensure a clear blood trail for tracking and recovering the animal.
- Good for medium-sized game
- Leaves large wound area for solid blood trail
- Includes o-rings for easy replacement and repair
- Less penetration means these are not suited for big game
- Wider blades may blow off course in windy conditions
Muzzy Blade broadheads are sold in a three-pack and weigh 125 grains. These broadheads feature razor-sharp stainless steel blades to help hunters take down larger game animals quickly and efficiently. The blades are designed to lock within the heads to increase durability and strength to the arrow unit.
If you’re hunting big game such as grizzly bear, large deer or elk, the Muzzy Blade broadheads can provide the strength you need to penetrate both thick flesh and muscle as well as bone with their special tip design. The broadhead creates a one-and-three-sixteenth of an inch cutting diameter, which is about the industry average. This diameter has the advantage of being large enough to create a good blood trail while providing enough penetration to kill the animal.
Although this broadhead stays sharp for an extended period of time, it can create a slight whistling sound during flight. Any sound can potentially warn the targeted game to danger. Some larger game animals can be dangerous if alerted to a hunter’s presence.
- Diamond sharpness
- Excellent penetration and cutting diameter
- Good for big game
- Slight whistling sound in flight
- Not ideal for smaller game
The 100-grain G5 Outdoor Striker broadhead features a cutting diameter of one-and-one-eighth inches. With its cut-on-contact design, this broadhead can penetrate thick-skinned medium to large game animals with minimal friction to the blades and kill them quickly and efficiently. The cutting diameter is close to industry average, providing hunters with a good balance of penetration depth and a large enough wound to leave a blood trail so that the animal can be tracked through difficult terrain.
These all-steel, replaceable blades feature an ANIX blade-locking system, which is one of the most efficient ways to secure blades, and are sold in a three-pack. They are completely spin tested and come with a one-year limited warranty. The razor-sharp, German Lutz blade gives this broadhead fine accuracy and cutting power, providing an excellent blood trail for hunters to follow. The G5 Striker broadhead flies quietly and accurately. However, the broadheads can break after a shot and changing the blades can be somewhat challenging. Be sure to carry the proper tools for replacing blades safely.
- Cut-on-contact design
- Leaves solid blood trail
- Replaceable, steel blades with locking system
- 100% spin tested
- Flies quietly and accurately
- Tends to break more easily
- Challenging to replace blades
Hunters can select this three-blade archery broadhead for small game hunting. The 100-grain broadhead comes in a 12-pack and is compatible with both a crossbow and a compound bow. With its sharp and durable blades, this broadhead is excellent for field practice as well as hunting rabbits, possums and coyotes that are darting through brush and tall grasses.
Sinbad Teck employs anodized aluminum for the broadhead’s nuts and shafts as well as stainless steel for its blades. In order to protect the hunter, the company has incorporated grabbing hooks into the design of the broadhead to ensure that the arrow is easily retrievable after the kill. This hunting broadhead measures 2.8 inches by just over an inch wide and features replaceable screw-in tips.
- Sharp, durable blades
- Compatible with crossbow and compound bow
- Effective in hunting through brush and rugged terrain
- Good for small game
- Not good for large animals
- Broadheads tend to be more fragile and require frequent replacement
The Toxic Broadhead from Flying Arrow Archery has a low profile and sharp cutting edge. This 100-grain broadhead features blades that spin open, grinding through flesh and bone and creating a large wound. Although these broadheads work well on less-than-perfect shots, they tend to be somewhat more fragile and break upon impact.
Blades are replaceable and feature a one-inch cutting diameter. The slightly smaller cutting diameter trades for excellent penetration. However, this broadhead requires more than 24 inches per pound of energy to enter its entire length.
- Sharp, spinning blades
- Replaceable blades
- Excellent penetration and cutting diameter
- More fragile heads can break on impact
- Requires greater than 24 inches per pound for maximum penetration
The broadheads from Posch are triple-blade, 100 grain and come in packages of 12. They are best used for smaller game in typical bow hunting. This product’s design works well for hunters going after rabbits, turkeys, coyotes or raccoons. With its feature of razor-sharp blades, these stainless steel broadheads are typically used for single shots and then replaced. Posch broadheads measure two-and-one-quarter inches in length with a one-and-one-sixth cutting diameter, which is the ideal design for broadheads used in small game hunting.
The company also offers an impact-resistant plastic case, featuring padded foam and a secure latch. The case, which measures roughly 7 inches by 5 inches by 2 inches, helps hunters safely transport and store broadheads when they are not in use. The added feature of a customized case helps protect hunters from injury that can easily be incurred from the ultra-sharp blades. Most injuries to hunters happen when unprotected sharp gear is being loaded into cars or being transported to the hunting site.
- Good for small game
- Sharp, stainless steel blades
- Comes with carrying case for safe transport
- Not good for large game
- Heads tend to break after single shot
As you can see from this round-up, it is much more important to select the right broadhead that matches your arrow, your bow and the game you are hunting. It would not make sense to use a broadhead designed to kill large game animals to put down a rabbit, neither would it be a good idea to use an expandable or mechanical broadhead on a traditional bow and arrow set-up.
In fact, mismatching broadheads, bows and arrow shafts can not only be detrimental to your hunting efforts, it could be dangerous to use all together.
Hunters should invest ample time researching which hunting gear will work best for their situations. Some archers who are more interested in target shooting may want to avoid broadheads completely. Those homesteaders or farmers who are trying to shoot small animals to protect their livestock may select broadheads like the Sibad Teck that are designed to accurately and quickly kill coyotes, possums or raccoons.
Hunters who are after whitetail deer in order to fill their freezers with venison sausage for the winter may be happier with a broadhead designed to pierce medium-skinned animals that are proven to leave a solid blood trail so they can track and field dress their catch.
Serious hunters who are trying to find their trophy bucks or after large game such as elk will want heavy-duty, diamond-sharp broadheads such as the G5 series. They will not only help hunters get their prize game but will also do so in a safe, efficient, and humane manner.
In the end, selecting the broadhead that matches specific hunting purposes and particular equipment will be the best solution for those in the broadhead market.